Porsche Automobil Holding SE has been downgraded by UBS from a "neutral" to a "sell" rating, with a revised price target of €32 per share. UBS's decision is based on updated financial models for Porsche's core holdings, including Volkswagen Group and Porsche AG. Analysts have identified challenges in revenue growth and profitability as key factors influencing the downgrade.
Despite expectations for revenue stabilization at €39 billion for Porsche AG by 2025, operating profit margins are only expected to marginally improve to 14.6%. Ongoing execution issues, weak cost discipline, and a suboptimal governance structure are seen as critical barriers to performance improvement.
The financial outlook for Volkswagen further complicates the situation for Porsche SE, with UBS maintaining a "sell" rating on Volkswagen and revising its price target down to €75. The complex restructuring efforts of Volkswagen in Germany, along with potential charges in the fourth quarter, are expected to strain dividend payments, which are crucial for Porsche SE's income stream.
Porsche SE's financial health is already under scrutiny, with a high net debt of €5.1 billion and a narrowing 30% net asset value discount viewed as unjustified. Analysts have expressed concerns about Porsche SE's ability to manage refinancing pressures starting in 2027, especially as dividends from key investments are projected to decline.
UBS's revised valuation of Porsche SE reflects a subdued outlook due to diminished growth expectations in its underlying assets. Structural inefficiencies and anticipated challenges in revenue generation raise questions about Porsche SE's long-term viability. The luxury automotive market, typically characterized by robust recovery patterns, is facing unique challenges that could hinder Porsche's performance. Strategic adjustments and improved governance are crucial for Porsche SE to regain investor confidence and stabilize its financial outlook.